Churches Often Make These 10 Dangerous Mistakes When Evaluating Pastors

Evaluations should be godly and redemptive. (Pexels)

I remember the first time a personnel committee of my church evaluated my ministry and me. I was young, in my early 20s, and I had never had anyone evaluate me to that point. I didn't like being evaluated then, and it still makes me uncomfortable at times—though I know it's necessary. Here are some mistakes I've seen churches make regularly in this process of evaluating pastors:

  1. Not evaluating the pastors at all: Even if they are the spiritual leaders, nothing should prohibit the church from evaluating their work and helping them grow. That's good stewardship of persons.
  2. Evaluating without established expectations on a written job description: With no written job description, you are asking a pastor to live up to everyone's expectations. No one can live up to that standard.
  3. Evaluating them only when the church is struggling: If that's the only time pastoral evaluation takes place, it's possible the motive is wrong—perhaps to help push the pastor out the door. Regular evaluations help avoid this problem.
  4. Evaluating on only the basis of growth and giving: These are not at all invalid criteria to use in evaluating pastors, but they should be only one part of the process. Stalled growth does not necessarily mean poor leadership, and increased growth is not always indicative of good leadership.
  5. Including uninvolved church members in the evaluation process: I've seen churches create personnel committees of business leaders who know how to evaluate personnel but who seldom, if ever, attend church. Unfaithful members should not carry this responsibility.
  6. Emphasizing only the negative: You can wear out a good pastor by continually dealing with negatives while failing to point out the numbers of people who continue to love and follow him.
  7. Pointing out concerns but offering no helpful corrective steps: Evaluations should be godly and redemptive—offering hope and help for a pastor who needs both. When evaluators have no plan to help overcome the negatives, they're essentially saying, "We're not very interested in helping you."
  8. Evaluating on the basis of hours in the office: Frankly, some of the best pastors I know aren't in their office much; they're outside the church walls doing outreach.
  9. Failing to ask about the pastors' spiritual walk: We assume all is in order here and then quickly address other organizational issues. We miss an opportunity to minister to the shepherds when we don't talk about their spiritual practices.
  10. Failing to check out available resources for evaluation: Some churches spend too much time trying to figure out how to evaluate a pastor. Do a search for "ways to evaluate pastors," and you will find resources. They may not always be inexpensive, but they will often help you save time.

What would you add?

Chuck Lawless is dean and vice-president of graduate studies and ministry centers at Southeastern Seminary in Wake Forest, North Carolina, where he also serves as professor of evangelism and missions. In addition, he is global theological education consultant for the International Mission Board of the Southern Baptist Convention.

This article originally appeared at chucklawless.com.

Get Spirit-filled content delivered right to your inbox! Click here to subscribe to our newsletter.

Dr. Steve Greene is now sharing stories, teachings, and conversations with guests who lead with love on Love Leads, a new podcast. Listen now.


Help Charisma stay strong for years to come as we report on life in the Spirit. Become an integral part of Charisma’s work by joining Charisma Media Partners. Click here to keep us strong!

Dr. Mark Rutland's

National Institute of Christian Leadership (NICL)

The NICL is one of the top leadership training programs in the U.S. taught by Dr. Mark Rutland. If you're the type of leader that likes to have total control over every aspect of your ministry and your future success, the NICL is right for you!

FREE NICL MINI-COURSE - Enroll for 3-hours of training from Dr. Rutland's full leadership course. Experience the NICL and decide if this training is right for you and your team.

Do you feel stuck? Do you feel like you’re not growing? Do you need help from an expert in leadership? There is no other leadership training like the NICL. Gain the leadership skills and confidence you need to lead your church, business or ministry. Get ready to accomplish all of your God-given dreams. CLICK HERE for NICL training dates and details.

The NICL Online is an option for any leader with time or schedule constraints. It's also for leaders who want to expedite their training to receive advanced standing for Master Level credit hours. Work through Dr. Rutland's full training from the comfort of your home or ministry at your pace. Learn more about NICL Online. Learn more about NICL Online.

Charisma Leader — Serving and empowering church leaders