A Guide to Assessing Internal Leadership Candidates


Many times people ask me, "William, we have a great candidate on staff who could be my successor. How should we figure out if he/she is the right person?"

Determining a new leader for your church is a high-pressure and high-impact decision that shouldn't be taken lightly. Here are some lessons I learned about assessing internal candidates.

1. Look in the family (with a warning). I think internal candidates are a fantastic place to start your search for a successor. That sounds like I'm working myself out of a job, but I'm not. The longest-standing metaphor I can find for succession is that of a heart transplant. If you talk to transplant doctors, you'll find out very quickly that there's one aspect of transplant that separates the best from the rest—the tissue match. You can find a very healthy heart and put it in a very healthy body, but if there is no tissue match, it can be a bad ending for everyone.

When doctors are looking for a kidney or heart transplant, where do they first look? Almost always, doctors will look for family members. But not every family member is the right tissue match, and the same goes for your organization.

Get Spirit-filled content delivered right to your inbox! Click here to subscribe to our newsletter.

Just as you would hire a transplant doctor to assess the efficacy of a good tissue match, organizations hire us to do the same. Many times we assess both internal candidates and external candidates, and it's a win for everyone involved. If an internal candidate is named as the successor, all parties can go to bed at night knowing the organization has looked everywhere on the planet and isn't just hiring someone they know but is hiring the right person for the job.

On the other hand, organizations will have an unnatural tendency to look at people they know rather than search for the unknown. Having an outside guide will help you as an organization look at both the internal and external and then objectively choose between the two.

2. Don't create a horse race. There aren't many cardinal rules in succession, but here's one of the few that I know. When working with a faith-based organization, it is not a good idea to pit candidates within the organization against one another for succession.

Many years ago, when Jack Welch was looking for his successor, he had three internal candidates at General Electric who could have taken his place. He told the three of them this, and the horse race was on. It sounded like a fresh and transparent way to find a new successor.

In a faith-based organization, this is a disaster waiting to happen. For starters, most faith-based organizations are much smaller than General Electric. And unlike the corporate world, faith-based organizations have donors, all of whom have favorite staff members. So not only are you putting employees against one another, but you may inadvertently set donors against one another as well as volunteers. In this case, an organization that is trying to do good in the world can find itself in a long season of internal conflict.

3. Take half the time you think you should. Many times when looking at an internal candidate, I find clients that have someone on staff who "isn't quite ready." A period of overlapping the outgoing leader with the incoming is often a good solution. The most common question I am asked about succession is "How long should an overlap be between my successor and me?"

I have yet to see an overlap go longer than two years and have a positive return. Most people think two years isn't long enough, but once they're going through the succession, two years is too long. I'm reminded of my mother's advice about packing for a trip. She used to say "Lay out everything you want to take on the trip, then put half of it back in the closet. Now you're packed for the trip." When you're looking at an overlap or a period of grooming your successor, take less time for overlap than you think you need to.

4. It's only nepotism if you stink. A question I've been asked many times is "William, what about my son or another family member?" I have one client who says, "You know, William, I've told my family that it's only nepotism if you stink." The fact of the matter is that many faith-based companies are similar to small businesses, and the vast majority of small businesses in the United States are family businesses. Nobody acts like an owner except owners. Nobody thinks like a founder except founders. And sometimes that means the very best successor is a family member.

However, there are some very deadly pitfalls to hiring the wrong family member as a successor. If you're considering a family member as a successor, I would strongly urge you to get a coach, consultant or outside opinion to help weigh the pluses and minuses. Hiring someone with experience in this area could make all the difference to getting the succession right. And getting it right with family is, in my experience, paramount. Nobody is more difficult to fire than family.

In Conclusion

Family may be a wonderful place to look for your successor. Internal staff members might also be great. Just realize that you will naturally have a bias toward internal candidates because choosing what is known is always more appealing than facing the unknown. That bias is natural, but it can keep you from making a wise decision.

After managing a couple of thousand successions in my time in this role, I can tell you that taking a little extra time, spending a little money to get it right and being careful will pay big dividends in the long run.

William Vanderbloemen is the CEO and founder ofVanderbloemen, which serves teams with a greater purpose by aligning their people solutions for growth: hiring, compensation, succession and culture. Through its retained executive search and consulting services, Vanderbloemen serves churches, schools, nonprofits, family offices and Christian businesses in all parts of the United States and internationally. Follow him on Twitter@wvanderbloemen.

Read articles like this one and other Spirit-led content in our new platform, CHARISMA PLUS.

Get Spirit-filled content delivered right to your inbox! Click here to subscribe to our newsletter.

Dr. Mark Rutland's

National Institute of Christian Leadership (NICL)

The NICL is one of the top leadership training programs in the U.S. taught by Dr. Mark Rutland. If you're the type of leader that likes to have total control over every aspect of your ministry and your future success, the NICL is right for you!

FREE NICL MINI-COURSE - Enroll for 3-hours of training from Dr. Rutland's full leadership course. Experience the NICL and decide if this training is right for you and your team.

Do you feel stuck? Do you feel like you’re not growing? Do you need help from an expert in leadership? There is no other leadership training like the NICL. Gain the leadership skills and confidence you need to lead your church, business or ministry. Get ready to accomplish all of your God-given dreams. CLICK HERE for NICL training dates and details.

The NICL Online is an option for any leader with time or schedule constraints. It's also for leaders who want to expedite their training to receive advanced standing for Master Level credit hours. Work through Dr. Rutland's full training from the comfort of your home or ministry at your pace. Learn more about NICL Online. Learn more about NICL Online.

Charisma Leader — Serving and empowering church leaders